Large Scale Lands and Benefit-Sharing Conundrum: Insights from
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.48346/IMIST.PRSM/ajlp-gs.v7i5.51028Keywords:
large scale land investment projects, benefit sharing, Galana Kulalu, Tana River, KenyaAbstract
The increasing trend of large-scale land investments by both local and international investors has had a significant impact on agricultural production in rural Africa over the past two and a half decades. Some of the investments have had transformative impacts, while others have resulted in negative outcomes. The outcomes of these projects are typically contingent on the unique circumstances of each case. This research article discusses the findings of a study conducted on the Galana Kulalu Food Security Project (GKFSP) in Galana Kulalu, Tana River County, Kenya. The Kenyan government to address food security challenges in the country and the surrounding region established the GKFSP. Given the historical marginalization of rural communities in Tana River County and their limited access to benefits from large-scale investments in land in the county, as well as the influence of commercial and political interests on land utilization and livelihoods, this study aimed to analyze benefit sharing from GKFSP within the context of large-scale land deals. The analyses of findings in this article rely on the primary data collected through key informant interviews and focus group discussions from, as well as observations of, key stakeholders in a purposively selected case study of GKFSP, particularly members of the communities neighboring the project as well as government and civil society representatives. Secondary sources of data involving land deals were also used to complement primary data from the study. Findings from the study highlight the importance of adopting responsive policies when entering into large-scale land deals to ensure equitable benefit sharing among different stakeholders, including the investors, local communities, and other relevant institutions. Failure to do so could lead to conflict dynamics that hinder project implementation and may even cause the failure of such land deals, leading to high turnover of investors and apathy within the local communities. Although it is acknowledged that large-scale land deals may result in lower profits compared to alternative investments, it is contended that the limited or absent sharing of benefits between investors and local communities and other stakeholders in relation to land deals is not solely attributable to the lack of profitability generated by the investments. Other factors that may be peculiar to each project are often at play, and these should be analyzed to form part of the negotiations involving large-scale land investments and benefit sharing.
References
Adino, D. (2020). Integrating Benefit Sharing with Compensation as a Poverty Risk Reduction Strategy for Persons Displaced by Large Dams: Focus on Thiba Dam Irrigation Development Project in Kenya. Journal of African Interdisciplinary Studies, 4(12), 53-72.
Ali, R. M. (2021). Understanding devolution in ethnic conflict management: a study of Tana River County in Kenya.
Atieo, C. & Boran, J. (2022). Law is life: Indigenous relationships to territory and navigating settler colonial property regimes in Canada. Land, 11(5), 609.
Andrews, N., & Cochrane, L. (2021). The transnational land rush in Africa. International political economy and the land rush in Africa: Trends, scale, narratives, and contestations. Palgrave Macmillan: Springer.
Anseeuw, W., Boche, M., Breu, T., Giger, M., Lay, J., Messerli, P., & Nolte, K. (2012). Transnational land deals for agriculture in the Global South. Analytical report based on the Land Matrix database, 1.
Antonelli, M., Bracco, S., Turvani, M. E., & Vicario, A. (2020). Large-scale land acquisitions in Sub-Saharan Africa and corporate social responsibility (CSR): insights from Italian investments. Sustainability Challenges in Sub-Saharan Africa I: Continental Perspectives and Insights from Western and Central Africa, 137-159.
Anuradha, R. V. (2000). Sharing the Benefit of biodiversity the Kani TBGRI deal in Kerala, India. Journal of International Wildlife Law and Policy, 3(2), 125-151.
Assembe-Mvondo, S., Brockhaus, M., & Lescuyer, G. (2013). Assessment of the effectiveness, efficiency and equity of benefit-sharing schemes under large-scale agriculture: Lessons from land fees in Cameroon. The European Journal of Development Research, 25, 641-656.
Balestri, S., & Maggioni, M. A. (2021). This land is my land! Large-scale land acquisitions and conflict events in Sub-Saharan Africa. Defence and Peace Economics, 32(4), 427-450.
Baumgartner, P., von Braun, J., Abebaw, D., & Müller, M. (2015). Impacts of large-scale land investments on income, prices, and employment: Empirical analyses in Ethiopia. World Development, 72, 175–190.
Boamah.F.(2015). Biofuels and land politics: connecting the disconnects in the debate about livelihoods impacts of jatropha biofuels land deals in Ghana.
Boone, C., Dyzenhaus, A., Manji, A., Gateri, C. W., Ouma, S., Owino, J. K., & Klopp, J. M. (2019). Land law reform in Kenya: Devolution, veto players, and the limits of an institutional fix. African affairs, 118(471), 215-237.
Borras Jr, S. M., & Franco, J. C. (2010). Contemporary discourses and contestations around pro‐poor land policies and land governance. Journal of Agrarian Change, 10(1), 1-32.
Borras Jr, S. M., Hall, R., Scoones, I., White, B., & Wolford, W. (2011). Towards a better understanding of global land grabbing: an editorial introduction. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 38(2), 209-216.
Breu, T., Bader, C., Messerli, P., Heinimann, A., Rist, S., & Eckert, S. (2016). Large-scale land acquisition and its effects on the water balance in investor and host countries. PLOS ONE, 11(3), e0150901.
Breuntrup, M. (2016). Let’s work together? Innovative social entrepreneurship in the field of youth policy welcomed by German local governments: A case study of the social enterprise. RheinFlake, http://purf.utwente.nl/essays/71543.
Byerlee, D., Deininger, K., Lindsay, J., Norton, A., Selod, H., & Stickler, M. (2011). Rising global interest in farmland: Can it yield sustainable and equitable Benefit? The World Bank
Cernea, M. M. (2008). Compensation and benefit sharing: Why resettlement policies and practices must be reformed. Water Science and Engineering, 1(1), 89-120.
Chanceline, B. (2019). Land grabbing and its impact on food security in Sub-Saharan Africa.
Cotula, L. (2013). The New Enclosures? Polanyi, international investment law and the global land rush. Third World Quarterly, 34(9), 1605-1629
Cotula, L., Oya, C., Codjoe, E.A., Eid, A., Kakraba-Ampeh, M., Keeley, J., Kidewa, A.I., Makwarimba, M., Seide, W.M., Nasha, W.O., Asare, R.O., & Rizzo, M. (2014). Testing claims about large land deals in Africa: Findings from a multi-country study. Journal of Development Studies, doi:10.1080/00220388.2014.901501.
Cotula, L., Vermeulen, S., Leonard, R., & Keeley, J. (2009). Land grab or development opportunity? Agricultural investment and international land deals in Africa. IIED/FAO/IFAD, London/Rome, ISBN:978-1-84369-741-1.
Cousins, B. (2009, March). Potential and pitfalls of ‘communal’land tenure reform: Experience in Africa and implications for South Africa. In Paper for the World Bank Conference on Land Governance in Support of the MDGs: Responding to New Challenges (pp. 9-10).
Cristian, S. & Editor, G. (2020). The parable of arable land: Characterizing large-scale land acquisitions through network analysis. PLoS One 15(10), e0240051, doi:10.137/journal.pone.0240051.
Crow, B., & Singh, N. (2000). Impediments and innovation in international rivers: The waters of South Asia. World Development, 28(11), 1907-1925.
De Juan, A., Geissel, D., Lay, J., & Lohmann, R. (2022). Large-scale land deals and social conflict: Evidence and policy implications (No. 328). GIGA Working Papers.
de LT Oliveira, G., McKay, B. M., & Liu, J. (2021). Beyond land grabs: new insights on land struggles and global agrarian change. In Beyond the Global Land Grab (pp. 1-18). Routledge.
Dell’Angelo, J., D’Odorico, P., & Rulli, M. C. (2017). Threats to sustainable development posed by land and water grabbing. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 26, 120-128.
Dinar, S., Dinar, A., & Kurukulasuriya, P. (2011). Scarcity and cooperation along international rivers: an empirical assessment of bilateral treaties. International Studies Quarterly, 55(3), 809-833.
D'Odorico, P., Rulli, M. C., Dell'Angelo, J., & Davis, K. F. (2017). New frontiers of land and water commodification: Socio‐environmental controversies of large‐scale land acquisitions. Land Degradation & Development, 28(7), 2234-2244.
Dudley, N. & Alexander, S. (2017). Will small farmers survive the twenty-first century and should they? Biodiversity, 18(2-3), 68-70.
Duvail, S., Médard, C., Hamerlynck, O., & Nyingi, D. W. (2012). Land and water grabbing in an East African coastal wetland: The case of the Tana delta. Water alternatives, 5, 322-343.
Enns, C. (2019). Infrastructure projects and rural politics in northern Kenya: the use of divergent expertise to negotiate the terms of land deals for transport infrastructure. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 46(2), 358-376
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) .(2012). Voluntary Guidelines on the Responsible Governance of Tenure of Land, Fisheries and Forests in the Context of National Food Security; Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO): Rome, Italy.
Giger, M., Oberlack, C., Anseeuw, W., Adelle, C., Bourblanc, M., Kiteme, B., & Messerli, P. (2019). How and why large-scale agricultural investments induce different socio-economic, food security, and environmental impacts: Evidence from Kenya, Madagascar, and Mozambique [913]. Global Land Programme.
Gironde, C., & Golay, C. (2015). Large-scale land acquisitions, livelihoods, and human rights in South-East Asia. Revue international de politique de développement, 6, 275–292
Gurr, T, R. (1970). Why Men Rebel. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Guyalo, A.K., Alemu, E.A., & Degaga, D.T. (2022). Impact of large-scale agricultural investments on the food security status of local communities in Gambella region, Ethiopia. Agriculture & Food Security, 11(1), 1-28.
Gyapong, A. (2020). Political dynamics of global land grabs: exploring the land-labour nexus on Ghana’s eastern corridor.
Hajjar, R., Ayana, A. N., Rutt, R., Hinde, O., Liao, C., Keene, S., Bandiaky-Badji, S., & Agrawal, A. (2020). Capital, labor, and gender: The consequences of large-scale land transactions on household labor allocation. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 47(3), 566–588
Kachika, T. (2017). Landgrabbing in Africa: a review of the impacts and the possible policy responses.
Kandel, M. (2017). Politics from below? Small-, mid-and large-scale land dispossession in Teso, Uganda, and the relevance of scale. In Global Land Grabbing and Political Reactions' from Below' (pp. 169-186). Routledge.
Kibugi, R., Mwathane, I., & Makathimo, M. (2016). Large scale land acquisitions for investment in Kenya: is the participation, and Benefit of affected local communities meaningful, and equitable?-a case study of the situation in Lamu, Isiolo and Siaya counties. Land Development and Governance Institute.
Kipkemoi, S.(2018). Natural Resources Based Conflict: Case Study of Tana River, County, Master Degree, University of Nairobi.
Klaphake, A. (2005). Cooperation on international rivers from an economic perspective: the concept of benefit sharing (No. 6/2005). Discussion paper.
Klaus, K. (2017). Contentious Land narrative and the no escalation of Election Violence: Evidence from Kenya’s Coastal Region.’’ Africa Studies Review 60(2):51-72.https://doi.org/10.1017/asr.2017.2.
Kumeh, E.M., & Omulo, G. (2019). Youths access to agricultural land in sub-Saharan Africa: A missing link in the global land-grabbing discourse. Land Use Policy, 89, doi:10.1016/j.landusepol.2019.104210.
Larmour, P. (1989). ‘Sharing the Benefit’: Customary Landowners and Natural Resource Projects in Melanesia. Pacific Viewpoint, 30(1), 56-74…
Leshore, L., & Minja, D. (2019). Factors affecting implementation of Vision 2030 flagship projects in Kenya: A case of the Galana-Kulalu irrigation scheme. International Academic Journal of Law and Society, 1(2), 395-410.
Liao, C., Jung, S., Brown, D. G., & Agrawal, A. (2020). Spatial patterns of large‐scale land transactions and their potential socio‐environmental outcomes in Cambodia, Ethiopia, Liberia, and Peru. Land Degradation & Development, 31(10), 1241-1251.
Liberti, S. (2013). Land grabbing: Journeys in the new colonialism. Verso Books.
Locher, M. (2016). ‘How come others are selling our land?’Customary land rights and the complex process of land acquisition in Tanzania. Journal of Eastern African Studies, 10(3), 393-412.
McMichael, P. (2011, April). The food regime in the land grab: articulating ‘global ecology’and political economy. In International Conference on Global Land Grabbing (pp. 6-8).
Millar, G. (2015). “We have no voice for that”: Land rights, power, and gender in rural Sierra Leone. Journal of Human Rights, 14(4), 445-462.
Millar, G. (2018). Co‐opting Authority and Privatizing Force in Rural Africa: Ensuring Corporate Power over Land and People. Rural Sociology, 83(4), 749-771.
Mulupi, L. (2018). Factors influencing the performance of flagship projects in Kenya: the case of Galana-Kulalu food security project in Kilifi County (Doctoral dissertation, University of Nairobi).
Müller-Mahn, D., Mkutu, K., & Kioko, E. (2021). Megaprojects—mega failures? The politics of aspiration and the transformation of rural Kenya. The European Journal of Development Research, 33, 1069-1090.
Munene, H. W., & Kinoti, K. (2020). Monitoring and evaluation approaches and performance of galana kulalu maize irrigation project, Kenya. International Academic Journal of Information Sciences and Project Management, 3(6), 293-311.
Ndi, F. A., & Batterbury, S. (2017). Land grabbing and the axis of political conflicts: insights from Southwest Cameroon. Africa Spectrum, 52(1), 33-63.
Nkansah-Dwamena, E. (2021). Can large-scale land acquisition deals improve livelihoods and lift people out of poverty in sub-Saharan Africa? Empirical evidence from Tanzania. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development, 10(3), 243-264.
Nkhata, B. A., Mosimane, A., Downsborough, L., Breen, C., & Roux, D. J. (2012). A typology of benefit sharing arrangements for the governance of social-ecological systems in developing countries. Ecology and Society, 17(1).
Nolte, K., & Väth, S. J. (2015). Interplay of land governance and large-scale agricultural investment: evidence from Ghana and Kenya. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 53(1), 69-92.
Onguny, P.& Gillies, Y. (2019). Land conflict in Kenya: A Comprehensive Overview of Literatire. http://journals. Open edition .org/eastafrica/879.
Pham Huu, T., Van Westen, A. C. M., & Zoomers, A. (2013). Compensation and resettlement policies after compulsory land acquisition for hydropower development in Vietnam: policy and practice. Land, 2(4), 678-704.
Phillips, D., Allan, J., Claassen, M., Granit, J., Jägerskog, A., Kistin, E., ... & Turton, A. (2008). The Two Analysis: Introducing A Methodology for the Trans-Boundary Waters Opportunity-report no. 23. Prepared for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs: Stockholm, Sweden.
Prause, L., & Billon, P. L. (2021). Struggles for land: comparing resistance movements against agro-industrial and mining investment projects. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 48(5), 1100-1123.
Qaddumi, H. (2008). Practical approaches to transboundary water benefit sharing (Vol. 292). London: Overseas Development Institute.
Regassa, A., Hizekiel, Y., & Korf, B. (2019). ‘Civilizing’ the pastoral frontier: Land grabbing, dispossession and coercive agrarian development in Ethiopia. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 46(5), 935–955.
Robert, S.W., Hafia, M., Axelle, G., Hauman, D., & Asuka, O. (2017). The impact of large-scale agricultural investments on local communities: Updated voices from the field. Food and Agriculture Global Practice Discussion Paper No. 12, Washington, DC, World Bank.
Ribot, J. C., & N. L. Peluso. (2003). “A Theory of Access.” Rural Sociology 68 (2): 153–181.
Robinson, J. A., Torvik, R., & Verdier, T. (2006). Political incentives of the resource booms (No. halshs-00754164).
Rose, K. (2019). An Assessment of the Agricultural Relations Between Israel and Kenya: Case Study of the Galana Kulalu Irrigation Scheme (Doctoral dissertation, University of Nairobi).
Sadoff, C. W., & Grey, D. (2002). Beyond the river: the Benefit of cooperation on international rivers. Water policy, 4(5), 389-403.
Sadoff, C. W., Whittington, D., & Grey, D. (2002). Africa's international rivers: an economic perspective. World Bank Publications.
Salverda, T. (2019). Facing criticism: An analysis of (land-based) corporate responses to the large-scale land acquisition countermovement. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 46(5), 1003–1020.
Sayles, M. L. (1984). Relative deprivation and collective protest: an impoverished theory?. Sociological Inquiry, 54(4), 449-465.
Schlimmer, S. (2018). Talking ‘land grabs’ is talking politics: land as politicised rhetoric during Tanzania’s 2015 elections, Journal of Eastern African Studies, 12:1, 83-101, DOI: 10.1080/17531055.2017.1410757.
Scoones, I., Hall, R., Borras Jr, S. M., White, B., & Wolford, W. (2013). The politics of evidence: methodologies for understanding the global land rush. Journal of Peasant Studies, 40(3), 469-483.
Scoones, L., Smalley. R., Hall. R.& Tsikata. D. (2019). Narratives of Scarcity: Framing the global Land Rush.’’.Geoforum 101:231-241. https://doi.org/10.10.1016.geoforum. Accessed on 4.4.2021.
Shete, M., & Rutten, M. (2015). Impacts of large-scale farming on local communities’ food security and income levels— Empirical evidence from Oromia Region, Ethiopia. Land Use Policy, 47, 282–292.
Soliev, I., & Theesfeld, I. (2017). Reframing for sustainability: Exploring transformative power of benefit sharing. Sustainability, 9(8), 1486.
Song, J., & Whittington, D. (2004). Why have some countries on international rivers been successful negotiating treaties? A global perspective. Water Resources Research, 40(5).
Stammler, F., & Peskov, V. (2008). Building a ‘culture of dialogue’among stakeholders in North-West Russian oil extraction. Europe-Asia Studies, 60(5), 831-849.
Sulle, E., & Nelson, F. (2013). Biofuels investment and community land tenure in Tanzania: The case of Bioshape, Kilwa District.
Tafon, R., & Saunders, F. (2019). The politics of land grabbing: State and corporate power and the (trans)nationalization of resistance in Cameroon. Journal of Agrarian Change, 19(1), 41–63. https://doi.org/10.1111/joac.12264
Toft, K. H. (2013). Are land deals unethical? The ethics of large-scale land acquisitions in developing countries. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 26, 1181-1198.
Tulone, A., Galati, A., Pecoraro, S., Carroccio, A., Siggia, D., Virzì, M., & Crescimanno, M. (2022). Main intrinsic factors driving land grabbing in the African countries’ agro-food industry. Land Use Policy, 120, 106225.
Vanclay, F., Esteves, A. M., Aucamp, I., & Franks, D. (2015). Social Impact Assessment: Guidance for assessing and managing the social impacts of projects.
Verma, R. (2014). Land grabs, power, and gender in East and Southern Africa: So, what's new?. Feminist Economics, 20(1), 52-75.
Vermeulen, S., & Cotula, L. (2013). Over the heads of local people: consultation, consent, and recompense in large-scale land deals for biofuels projects in Africa. In The Politics of Biofuels, Land and Agrarian Change (pp. 337-354). Routledge.
Walwa, W. J. (2020). Growing farmer-herder conflicts in Tanzania: the licenced exclusions of pastoral communities interests over access to resources. The Journal of Peasant Studies, 47(2), 366-382.
White, B., Borras, S.M., Jr, Hall, R., Scoones, I., & Wolford, W. (2013). The new enclosures: Critical perspectives on corporate land deals. Routledge, pp. 13-42.
Wily, L. A. (2011). ‘The law is to blame’: the vulnerable status of common property rights in sub‐Saharan Africa. Development and change, 42(3), 733-757.
Wolf, A. T. (2007). Shared waters: Conflict and cooperation. Annu. Rev. Environ. Resour., 32, 241-269.
Wolford, W.W., White, B., Scoones, I., Hall, R., Edelman, M., & Borras, S.M. (2024). Global land deals: What has been done, what has changed, and what’s next? The Journal of Peasant Studies, 1-38.
Yengoh, G.T., Sleen, K., Armah, F.A. & Ness, B. (2016). Factors of vulnerability: How large-scale land acquisitions take advantage of local and national weaknesses in Sierra Leon. Land Use Policy,
Butkevičienė, E., & Rabitz, F. (2022). Sharing the benefits of asteroid mining. Global Policy, 13(2), 247-258.
ADDITIONAL READING
Butkevičienė, E., & Rabitz, F. (2022). Sharing the benefits of asteroid mining. Global Policy, 13(2), 247-258.
Cernea, M. M. (2008). Compensation and benefit sharing: Why resettlement policies and practices must be reformed. Water Science and Engineering, 1(1), 89-120.
Soliev, I., & Theesfeld, I. (2020). Benefit sharing for solving transboundary commons dilemma in Central Asia. International Journal of the Commons, 14(1), 61-77.
Deininger, K., & Xia, F. (2016). Quantifying spillover effects from large land-based investment: The case of Mozambique. World Development, 87, 227-241.
Baumgartner, P., Von Braun, J., Abebaw, D., & Müller, M. (2015). Impacts of large-scale land investments on income, prices, and employment: Empirical analyses in Ethiopia. World Development, 72, 175-190.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 African Journal on Land Policy and Geospatial Sciences
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
The African Journal on Land Policy and Geospatial Sciences (AJLP&GS) is made available under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/. Authors with free access retain the copyright of their manuscripts. All open access manuscripts are published under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that the original work is properly cited. The use of general descriptive names, trade names, trademarks, etc. in this publication, even if not specifically identified, does not imply that applicable laws and regulations do not protect these names. Even though the advice and information in this journal are true and accurate as of the date of its publication, neither the authors, the editor, nor the publisher can assume any legal responsibility for any errors or omissions.
