INFORMAL REAL ESTATE MARKETS: Exploring the Controversies in the Literature
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.48346/IMIST.PRSM/ajlp-gs.v6i3.38812Keywords:
Informal, institution, property rights, real estate marketsAbstract
Are “informal real estate markets” really markets? Alternatively, are “informal property rights” tradable? A few years ago, just the mention of these concepts in a title would render it a misnomer. The aim of this paper is to explore the controversies in literature around the use of the concept “informal real estate markets”. The term “informal” comes with different connotations in literature; and for many years it denoted “illegality”. Thus, the use of “informal” as a prefix on real estate markets would be absurd or a misnomer in neo-classical economics whose definition of market transactions relied on fully titled private property rights. By implication, an informal real estate market trades in informal property rights. This paper shows that the use of the concept “informal real estate market” and by extension “informal property rights”, is now finding acceptance in scholarly literature. One of the underpinning reasons is the “new” understanding of “rules” as institutions and the re-definition of “markets” within institutional economics. This has resulted in the redefinition of key concepts in support of the operation and study of informal real estate markets. The paper is based largely on in-depth literature review, observations and original thought. The paper argues that the functioning of informal real estate markets is consistent with the theory on institutions.
References
Adiaba, S., Hammond, F., Proverbs, D., Lamond, J. and Booth, C., 2011, July. Sources Of Deficient Information Regime In Urban Real Estate Markets In Sub-Saharan African Countries. In West Africa Built Environment Research (Waber) Conference 19-21 July 2011 Accra, Ghana (p. 845).
Anim-Odame, W., 2012. The nascent residential investment market in Ghana. Journal of Real Estate Literature, 20(2), pp.289-303.
Baltrusis, N., 2004. The informal real estate market in favelas in the metropolitan area in São Paulo. In International conference on Adequate and Affordable Housing for All held on June (pp. 24-27).
Birch, E.L., Chattaraj, S. and Wachter, S.M. eds., 2016. Slums: How informal real estate markets work. University of Pennsylvania Press.
Bouwmeester, J. and Hartmann, T., 2021. Unraveling the self-made city: The spatial impact of informal real estate markets in informal settlements. Cities, 108, p.102966.
Bruce, J.W. and Knox, A., 2009. Structures and stratagems: Making decentralization of authority over land in Africa cost-effective. World Development, 37(8), pp.1360-1369.
Bubb, R., 2013. The evolution of property rights: state law or informal norms?. The Journal of Law and Economics, 56(3), pp.555-594.
Chattaraj, S., 2016. Property markets without property rights: Dharavi’s informal real estate market. In Slums (pp. 94-106). University of Pennsylvania Press.
Chimhowu, A. and Woodhouse, P., 2005, December. Vernacular land markets and the changing face of customary land tenure in Africa. In Forum for Development Studies (Vol. 32, No. 2, pp. 385-414). Taylor & Francis Group.
Chimhowu, A. and Woodhouse, P., 2006. Customary vs private property rights? Dynamics and trajectories of vernacular land markets in Sub‐Saharan Africa. Journal of agrarian change, 6(3), pp.346-371.
Chimhowu, A. and Woodhouse, P., 2010. Forbidden but not suppressed: a ‘vernacular’land market in Svosve Communal Lands, Zimbabwe. Africa, 80(1), pp.14-35.
Chimhowu, A., 2019. The ‘new’ African customary land tenure. Characteristic, features and policy implications of a new paradigm. Land use policy, 81, pp.897-903.
Colin, J.P. and Woodhouse, P., 2010. Interpreting land markets in Africa. Africa, 80(1), pp.1-13.
Daniel, D. and IfejikaSperanza, C., 2020. The role of blockchain in documenting land users' rights: The canonical case of farmers in the vernacular land market. Frontiers in blockchain, 3, p.19.
Deininger, K., Ali, D.A. and Alemu, T., 2011. Impacts of land certification on tenure security, investment, and land market participation: evidence from Ethiopia. Land Economics, 87(2), pp.312-334.
Galal, A. and Razzaz, O., 2001. Reforming land and real estate markets (Vol. 2616). World Bank Publications.
Hardin, G., 1968. The tragedy of the commons: the population problem has no technical solution; it requires a fundamental extension in morality. Science, 162(3859), pp.1243-1248.
Henry, J.K., 1999. Property rights, markets and economic theory: Keynes versus neoclassicism – again. Review of Political Economy, 11(2), pp. 151-170.
Kalabamu, F.T., 2021. A commentary on Botswana’s 2019 national land policy. Land Use Policy, 108, p.105563.
Koczberski, G., Numbasa, G., Germis, E. and Curry, G.N., 2017. Informal Land Markets in Papua New Guinea. Kastom, Property and Ideology, p.145.
Kumwenda, Morgan, F. Shumba, N. Ncube, D. Antonio, H. Nyamweru, J. Gitau, and A. Chileshe. "Innovations for securing tenure rights on customary lands through traditional authorities: Experiences from Chamuka Chiefdom, Zambia." In Proceedings of the World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty, Washington, DC, USA, pp. 19-23. 2018.
Jain, N., Chileshe, R., Muwowo, F. and Lupiya, M., 2016. Perceptions of customary land tenure security in western province of Zambia. Int'l J. Soc. Sci. Stud., 4, p.78.
Lanjouw, J.O. and Levy, P.I., 2002. Untitled: A study of formal and informal property rights in urban Ecuador. The Economic Journal, 112(482), pp.986-1019.
Min, S., Waibel, H. and Huang, J., 2017. Smallholder participation in the land rental market in a mountainous region of Southern China: Impact of population aging, land tenure security and ethnicity. Land Use Policy, 68, pp.625-637.
Mooya, M.M., 2009. Real estate markets and poverty alleviation in Namibia's urban informal settlements: an institutional approach (Doctoral dissertation, University of Pretoria).
Mooya, M.M., 2011. Making urban real estate markets work for the poor: Theory, policy and practice. Cities, 28(3), pp.238-244.
Mooya, M.M. and Cloete, C.E., 2007. Informal urban property markets and poverty alleviation: A conceptual framework. Urban studies, 44(1), pp.147-165.
Mooya, M.M. and Cloete, C.E., 2010. Property rights, real estate markets and poverty alleviation in Namibia's urban low income settlements. Habitat International, 34(4), pp.436-445.
Munshifwa, E.K., 2015. Property rights and the production of the urban built environment in Zambia. (Doctoral dissertation, University of Cape Town).
Munshifwa, E.K., Makashini-Masiba, L. and Chileshe, C., 2018, March. Exploring the Interface Between Formal and Informal Real Estate Markets in Facilitating Legally Binding Transactions in Zambian Cities. Urban Forum, 29(1), pp. 19-32.
Munshifwa, E.K., 2019. Adaptive resistance amidst planning and administrative failure: The story of an informal settlement in the city of Kitwe, Zambia. Town and Regional Planning, 75, pp.66-76.
Munshifwa, E.K. and Mooya, M.M., 2013. Theorising urban form in developing countries: Informal property markets and the production of the built environment. Retrieved from https://extranet.sioe.org/uploads/isnie2014/munshifwa_mooya.pdf
Munshifwa, E.K. and Mooya, M.M., 2016. Property rights and the production of the urban built environment–evidence from a Zambian city. Habitat International, 51, pp.133-140.
Mushinge, A., Simposya, A.M. and Chowa, S., 2020. Threats of Statutory Tenure on Customary Land in Zambia: Evidence from Chamuka Chiefdom in Chisamba District. African Journal on Land Policy and Geospatial Sciences, 3(2), pp.41-52.
Ngongola, C., 1996. Land tenure reform in Botswana: post-colonial developments and future prospects. SA Publiekreg SA Public Law, 11(1), pp.1-29.
Obeng-Odoom, F., 2015. Informal real estate brokerage as a socially-embedded market for economic development in Africa. Real estate, construction and economic development in emerging market economies. Routledge, London, pp.224-238.
Opoko, A.P., Oluwatayo, A.A., Amole, B.A.Y.O. and Adeyemi, E.A., 2018. Role of actors in informal settlements real estate market. Journal of Social Research and Policy, 9(1), pp.55-68.
Opoko, A.P., Oluwatayo, A.A., Amole, B. and Adeyemi, E., 2020. How different actors shape the real estate market for informal settlements in Lagos. Environment and Urbanization, 32(2), pp.371-388.
Perlman, J.E., 2016. The formalization of informal real estate transactions in Rio’s favelas. In Slums (pp. 58-82). University of Pennsylvania Press.
Portes, A., Castells, M. and Benton, L.A. eds., 1989. The informal economy: Studies in advanced and less developed countries. JHU Press.
Renaud, B., 2003. Speculative behaviour in immature real estate markets, lessons of the 1997 Asia financial crisis. Urban Policy and Research, 21(2), pp.151-173.
Sagashya, D.G.G. and Tembo, E., 2022. Zambia: Private sector investment in security of land tenure. From piloting using technology to National rollout. African Journal on Land Policy and Geospatial Sciences, 5(1), pp.031-049.
Seidler, V., 2010. Why did Botswana end up with Good Institutions: The Role of Culture and Colonial Rule. Available at SSRN 3051011.
Siame, C.G., 2010. Broadening the tax base: A case for the informal real estate sector in Zambia (Doctoral dissertation, Rhodes University).
Silva, M.C.D.A., 2016. Between statistics and the city: enrolment and production of social demand for apartments in the Minha Casa Minha Vida housing program. Cadernos Metrópole, 18, pp.237-256.
Smith, H., 2018. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Housing Studies, 33(3), pp. 495-497.
Tembo, E., Minango, J. and Sommerville, M., 2018. Zambia’s National Land Titling Programme–Challenges and Opportunities. In Annual World Bank Land and Poverty Conference (pp. 19-23).
Umar, B.B. and Nyanga, P.H., 2022. Customary Land Certification, Governance and Natural Resource Use in Zambia: A Social Learning Approach. The European Journal of Development Research, pp.1-31.
Wong, K.K. and Zhao, X.B., 1999. The influence of bureaucratic behavior on land apportionment in China: the informal process. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 17(1), pp.113-125.
Woodruff, C., 2001. Review of De Soto's The mystery of capital. Journal of Economic Literature, 39(4), pp.1215-1223.
Yunus, N., Hansz, J.A. and Kennedy, P.J., 2012. Dynamic interactions between private and public real estate markets: Some international evidence. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 45(4), pp.1021-1040.
Zhang, M. and He, S., 2020. Informal property rights as relational and functional: Unravelling the relational contract in China's informal housing market. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 44(6), pp.967-988.
