Over promising while Under Delivering: Implementation of Kenya’s Community Land Act

Collins Odote Oloo, Rahma Hassan, Husna Mubarak

Abstract


Kenya’s constitution of 2010 provides for recognition, protection, and registration of community land. This is significant because it recognizes customary tenure after decades of historical bias towards private property and brings to the fore the uniqueness of the African commons. We revisit the debate on managing communal land by reviewing the process of implementation of the Community Land. The paper is based on a review of the legal framework, discussions on the implementation of the Community Land Act and authors interaction with communities through workshops. It concludes that while the Act promises greater protection for commons, implementation challenges continue to hinder realization of the promised rights and benefits. Procedural uncertainty in the implementation process, tension in the formalization of customary tenure and institutional overlaps are identified as key bottlenecks in the process.  The paper argues that laws should be aligned to community systems and practices to achieve best results.


Keywords


Kenya, Community land, African commons, Constitution, customary tenure

Full Text:

File PDF

References


AAdams, M., S. Sibanda and S. Turner (2000) ‘Land Tenure Reform and Rural Livelihoods in Southern Africa’, in C. Toulmin and J. Quan (eds) Evolving Land Rights, Policy and Tenure in Africa, pp. 135–49. London: DFID/IIED/NRI

Alden Wily, L. (2003) ‘Community-based Atlantic Tenure Management: Questions and Answers about Tanzania’s New Village Land Act, 1999’. Issue Paper Number 120. London: International Institute for Environment and Development.

AUC-ECA-AfDb (2009), Framework and Guidelines on Land Policy in Africa

Bassett, E. (2017) The Challenge of Reforming Land Governance in Kenya under the 2010 Constitution. Cambridge University Press

Bennett, T.W (2004) Customary Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town)

Bruce, J. W. (1993) ‘Do Indigenous Tenure Systems Constrain Agricultural Development?’, in T. J. Bassett and D. E. Crummey (eds) Land in African Agrarian Systems, pp. 35–56. Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.

Clarke, R.A. 2009. 'Securing Communal Land Rights to Secure Sustainable Development in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Critical Analysis and Policy Considerations', Law, Environment and Development 5(2): 130-151

Cossins, N., & M Upton (1987). ‘The Borana Pastoral System of Southern Ethiopia’. Agricultural Systems, 25(3), 199–218.

Cousins B. (2008) ‘Characterising “Communal” Tenure: Nested Systems and Flexible Boundaries’ in Claassens A and Cousins B (eds) Land, Power and Custom (UCT Press) Cape Town

FAO (2019) Report on the Community Land Act Implementation in Kenya, Assessing Perception, Opportunities and Challenges. (unpublished, on file with authors).

Fitzpatrick, D. (2005) ‘Best Practice Options for the Legal Recognition of Customary Tenure’. Development and Change 36(3)

Gilbert, A. (2002). ‘On the Mystery of Capital and the Myths of Hernando de Soto: What Difference Does Legal Title Make?’ International Development Planning Review, 24(1)

Hardin, G. (1968). ‘The Tragedy of the Commons’ 162 Science 1243-1248

Hess, C. and E. Ostrom (2003) ‘Ideas, Artifacts, and Facilities: Information as A Common-pool Resource’ LCP 111-146

Kameri- Mbote, P. (2013). ‘Preface: Securing the Land and Resource Rights of Pastoral Peoples in East Africa’. Nomadic Peoples,

Kameri-Mbote, P., C. Odote, C. Musembi & M Kamande (2013) ‘Ours by Right: Law, Politics, and Realities of Community Property in Kenya’. Nomadic Peoples, 17(1). The White Horse Press.

Kanyinga, K. (2009). ‘The Legacy of the White Highlands: Land Rights, Ethnicity, and the Post-2007 Election Violence in Kenya’. Journal of Contemporary African Studies: Kenya’s Uncertain Democracy: The Electoral Crisis of 2008, 27(3), 325–344.

Kibugi, R. (2009). ‘A Failed Land Use Legal and Policy Framework for The African Commons? Reviewing Rangeland Governance In Kenya’. Journal of Land Use & Environmental Law, 24(2), 309–336.

Lenaola, I. (1998) ‘Land Tenure in Pastoral Lands’ in C. Juma and J.B Ojwang (eds) In Land We Trust: Environment, Private Property and Constitutional Development, Acts Press Nairobi

Migai-Akech J. (2001) ‘Rescuing Indigenous Tenure from the Ghetto of Neglect: Inalienability and the Protection of Customary Land Rights in Kenya’, Ecopolicy Series 1, Acts Press.

Molen, P. (2002) The Dynamic Aspect of Land Administration: An Often-forgotten Component in System Design’. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 26, 361-381.

Moyo, K. (2017) ‘Women’s Access to Land in Tanzania: The Case of Makete District’. Ph.D. Thesis, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 2017.

Musembi, C.N(2007) ‘De Soto and Land Relations in Rural Africa: Breathing Life into Dead Theories about Property Rights’, Third World Quarterly, 28:8, 1457-1478, DOI: 10.1080/01436590701637334.

Mwangi, E. (2007) ‘The Puzzle of Group Ranch Subdivision in Kenya’s Maasai Land’. Development and Change, 38(5), 889–910.

Mwangi, E. (2009) ‘Property Rights and Governance of Africa’s Rangelands: A Policy Overview’. Natural Resources Forum 33.2: 160–170.

Mweseli, TOA (2000), ‘The Centrality of Land in Kenya: Historical Background and Legal Perspective’ in SC Wanjal(ed) Essays on Land Law: The Reform Debate in Kenya. University of Nairobi. 3-24

Odote, C. (2O21) ‘The Place of Communal Land Rights in Africa’s Land Reform Discourses (A book symposium); Rethinking Land Reform in Africa: New ideas, Opportunities and Challenges (2020) Africa Development Bank. Available at https://www.afronomicslaw.org/category/analysis/place-communal-land-rights-africas-land-reform-discourse.

Odote, C. & P Kameri-Mbote (2016) ‘Introduction’ in Collins Odote and Patricia Kameri-Mbote (eds), Breaking the Mould: Lessons for Implementing Community Land Rights in Kenya. 1-9.

Odote, C. (2013), ‘The Dawn of Uhuru: Implications of Constitutional Recognition of Communal Land Rights in Kenya’. 17(1) Nomadic Peoples Journal 87-105

Odote, C. (2017) ‘The Conundrum of Institutional Arrangements to Govern Community Land in Kenya’ in Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Collins Odote, The Gallant Academic: Essays in Honour of H.W.O. Okoth-Ogendo (School of Law University of Nairobi) 119-145.

Ogolla DB & J Mugabe (1996), ‘Land Tenure Systems and Natural Resource Management’, in Juma, C and J.B Ojwang(eds), In Land We Trust: Environment, Private Property and Constitutional Development (Initiative Publishers and Zed Books.

Okoth Ogendo, HWO. (1991), ‘Formalising “Informal Property” Rights Systems: The Problem of Land Rights Reform in Africa’

Okoth-Ogendo HWO (2008) ‘The Nature of Land Rights under Indigenous Law in Africa’ in Claassens A and Cousins B (eds) Land, Power and Custom

Okoth-Ogendo, HWO (2000) ‘Legislative Approaches to Customary Tenure and Tenure Reform in East Africa’, in C. Toulmin and J. Quan (eds) Evolving Land Rights, Policy and Tenure in Africa, pp. 123–34. London: DFID/IIED/NRI

Okoth-Ogendo, HWO (2002), ‘The Tragic African Commons: A Century of Expropriation, Suppression and Subversion’ 4 Land Reform and Agrarian Change in Southern Africa, Occasional Paper. PLAAS.

Okoth-Ogendo, HWO. (1989)"Some issues of theory in the study of tenure relations in African agriculture" Africa: Journal of the International African Institute 617

Okoth-Ogendo, HWO. (1991) Tenants of the Crown: Evolution of Agrarian Law and Institutions in Kenya, Actspress.

Ostrom. (1990) Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action

Peters, PE, (2020) ‘The Significance of Descent-based ‘Customary’ Land Management for Land Reform and Agricultural Futures in Africa’ in Ochieng Cosmas (ed). Rethinking Land Reform in Africa: New Ideas, Opportunities and Challenges, African Development Bank. 70-83

Quan, J. (2000) ‘Land Boards as A Mechanism for the Management of Land Rights in Southern Africa’, in C. Toulmin and J. Quan (eds) Evolving Land Rights, Policy and Tenure in Africa, pp. 197–205. London: DFID/IIED/NRI

Republic of Kenya (2009), Sessional paper Number 3 of 2009 on National Land Policy.

Republic of Kenya (2010) Constitution of Kenya. Government Printer .

Republic of Kenya (2016) Community Land Act, Government Printer.

Ribot, J. and N Peluso (2003). ‘A Theory of Access’. Rural Sociology: 2:153-181

Society for International Development (2004), Pulling Apart: Facts and Figures on Inequality in Kenya

Wily L.A (2017) ‘The Fate of Res Communis in Africa: Unfinished Business’ in Patricia Kameri-Mbote and Collins Odote, The Gallant Academic: Essays in Honour of H.W.O. Okoth Ogendo (School of Law University of Nairobi) 103-118

Wily, A. (2001). ‘Reconstructing the African Commons’. Africa Today, 48(1), 77–99.

World Bank (2003) Report on Land. World Bank Policy Review

World Bank (2016) Women, Business and the Law 2016: Getting to Equal




DOI: https://doi.org/10.48346/IMIST.PRSM/ajlp-gs.v4i2.22915